Hot Tips & Topics

We are dedicated to providing you with a comprehensive collection of relevant and up-to-date K-12 education news and editorials. For teachers, by teachers.

Ed Reform: Longer School Days or Better School Days?

Adam Heenan, The Classroom Sooth


Longer School Days

Time is a valuable thing.  I often wish I had more of it.  I can pretty much say with confidence that you, Reader, probably wish you had some more too.

I don’t like to waste people’s time.  I don’t believe that any of us who engage in something we love want to either. 


When I form my lessons, teach a classroom full of high school students, or present information to my colleagues, I don’t want others to wish they were somewhere else. 


Related Articles
Person drawing a brain on a wall. The brain has the words leadership written on it.
Students need to be taught critical thinking skills, which they will need to...
3 kids sitting in front of a table.
8 transformative technology in the classroom skills required of the digitally...
Teacher talking to a young student at a table in class.
7 essential whole brain teaching steps that teachers must incorporate into...
Teacher reading to students, who sit in a circle.
We examine why classroom management procedures are important and how to teach...
Students sitting around a table with Tic Tac Toe on it.
Classroom games add flair and student engagement to more tedious, yet necessary...

Learning is at its best when students are engaged. Engagement can look like a variety of things: a student hard at work on his or her own composition, a thoughtful classroom discussion about ethics, participation in the school science fair, or designing an exercise regimen in P.E.

Teachers do not believe that what we teach is a waste of time.  We can engage students easily when things are important to us.


After reflecting on Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel's efforts to adopt longer school days in CPS schools, I can't help but consider the controversial question:

Is a longer school day necessary to provide students with a high quality education?

Efforts in Action for Longer School Days

During his run for office, Chicago Mayor Rahm Emanuel campaigned on a promise to deliver a longer school day and school year in Chicago. This longer school day concept has proven to be overwhelmingly popular among non-educators, and isn’t even that un-popular with some teachers. In fact, a handful of Chicago Public Schools have since adopted the new extended school schedule without union support. Obviously, students aren’t crazy about it, but we’ll get to that later.

More time in the school has the potential to look like a lot of things.  Emily at RosieSays illustrates different ideas of what “57 more hours” each school year could look like and breaks out a meaningful number: 10 extra days of school a year.  Mayor Emanuel is envisioning more time for math.  I would like more time for civics, art, and health education.

School Days: Quality vs. Quantity

But like the Academy Awards or tapeworms, “longer isn’t necessarily better.”  After a while, things deteriorate and can even become painful.  School is no exception.  When we start to solve schooling issues from the position of lengthening the school day, we will create more problems than solutions because that time and money will have to be cut from something else.

By extending the school days, schools will need to cut after-school programs, sports and clubs, and make-up credits (night school).  Graduation rates will plummet (further) when we see that kids who can’t make up classes they failed the first time have no second chance to learn.

Outside of the classroom, students’ lives will deteriorate: students will need to quit their after-school jobs.  They will get home much later in the evening. 


The vast majority of Chicago students use public transportation to get to school. Many already start and end their day away from home without sunlight.  They will spend less time with their families, which we know won’t help a student to succeed in school.

School reform needs to start from the position of changing what we are already doing in schools with the hours that we are there.  When students are spending hours each month prepping for and taking tests that neither inform instruction nor ensure meaningful outcomes, then we are wasting our time and their time.

Creating a Better School Day

We don’t need a longer school day; we need a “Better School Day” replete with study hall, recess, fully resourced classrooms, and schools that don’t resemble prisons. 


We need healthy meals and physical education that burns off enough of students’ energy to help them focus on writing and reading when they sit still. 

We need theatre, music, and arts education so students have something to write and read about. 

We need civic education to teach students how to leverage power in the world, especially as they become adults.

I think if we saw these changes, we might see that six and a half hours each day (eight, when we include homework and studying) would be well-spent, resulting in young people ready for society by the time they graduate.

Education reform must begin and end with what and why we are teaching and learning.  Those who want to legislate longer school days without considering the logistics will realize the hard way that they are creating more problems and wasting everyone’s time.

It leaves me wondering if youth will still be wasted on the young.


Do you think a longer school day will provide students with a higher quality of education? Why or why not? Share with us in the comments section!

Reprinted with permission from the author. Adam Heenan teaches high school social studies in Chicago, IL. He blogs at and tweets @ClassroomSooth Originally posted on The Classroom Sooth blog.