News, Recommendations and Resources

By Teachers, For Teachers

  open
Today's
Date
mar
21

TeachHUB Blog

Terminating Text Books?

Hasta la vista, text books.

 

California Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is launching a state-wide initiative to encourage schools to explore online, open source instructional materials instead of textbooks, according to an eSchoolNews report.

 

This is both a move toward the current trends in digital media and a desperate attempt to confront the $24 billion budget deficit in the state. Existing online resources are being screened to determine if they meet state standards.

 

Kathy Christie, chief of staff at the Education Commission of the States, said Schwarzenegger's plan appears to be the most ambitious of its kind in the nation, although Illinois is also studying digital textbooks. [GO ILLINI]

 

The future of this initiative is still “cloudy” (pun apologies, but I couldn’t resist). It still needs to pass, the budget savings probably wouldn’t be noticeable until well into the future, and Cali schools don’t have the computers to sustain this shift.

 

Regardless, Cali might be starting the trend for the rest of the country to follow.

 

As evidenced by another pending bill in the Golden State, the latest version of the Amazon Kindle is shaping up to be a hand-held version of this vision that could help in the transition.

 

The Kindle is a wireless reading device that lets you download books, newspaper, blogs, etc from anywhere. It store up to 1500 books, most classics are even available for free download and more digital textbooks are being made available. As an added instructional bonus, there’s a text-to-speech feature that would assist struggling readers and help with pronunciation and fluency in ESL students.

 

The biggest appeal for me, personally, is that the Kindle mimics the feel of a book (I LOVE the physicality of a book and would really miss it – Luckily, no rich benefactors are offering to buy me one, so that’s a worry for another day). These 2.0 iStudents may be used to working on computers all the time, but there is a need to maintain the mobility of books you can carry everywhere with you. Otherwise, "the dog ate my homework" will just be replace with "why don't you ask Comcast why I couldn't read that chapter?" as the go-to student excuse.

 

I’m not the only one that thinks the Kindle (or products like it) will be wave of the K-12 future.

 

Practically speaking, there is no way that any district 10 years from now is going to be able to resist buying a $200 Kindle for their students at the beginning of their 7th grade year and then simply buying textbook updates as the student progresses. The money saved and hassle avoided will be tremendous.

 

~Chris Edwards, teacher Full blog post

 

Are you ready for the digital revolution to terminate your textbooks or do you like things the way they are? Share in the comments section!


10 comments
< prev
Read Other TeachHUB Blogs
next >

Comments

Erlinda Garcia June 19, 2009 at 04:14pm
I'm all for the idea of "terminating" textbooks! I swear I developed back problems from carrying around those heavy books! Besides it's a GREAT way to cut back on paper usage!

P.S. Yay Illini!! :)
Jennifer Leighton June 23, 2009 at 03:09pm
I am concerned about abolising text books. I have a cousin that read several books online. There is something about curling up to read an enjoyable novel. Yes, it would be easier to grab a kindle and most likely cheaper, but it takes a sort of intimacy away from reading.
zoe wilson June 24, 2009 at 12:20am
we're the golden state out here; florida is the sunshine state.
i just wonder how the hell this is all going to be financed. and the equity issues are out of this world. i can't even take a class to the computer lab without having 5-10 minutes of class time being used up waiting for things to load...kindles being lost, destroyed, stolen, sold...i mean, how many replacement kindles does each kid get? we're chasing kids down for every nickel and dime they owe for lunches but we're supposed to finance enough equitable technology for the entire k-12 population of this state? we don't need new textbooks; we need to meet the bottom of maslow's hierarchy of needs so our students can actually learn!
Administrator June 24, 2009 at 12:23pm
Zoe - thanks for the correction. Now we're golden!

I think you're right about the investment capital. These budgets seem to be made in a dream world where every kid will keep their kindle for 6 years and no technology requires upkeep.
John Faig June 24, 2009 at 12:23pm
I think textbooks are an impediment for improving education. Aside from the costs, they allow teachers to coast into "content coverage" mode. Textbooks are raw content with little pedagogy behind them. Textbooks have significant resources. They should have several ways to teach each lesson - not a random technology project sprinkled here and there. If you don't buy that they are bad, then they hurt teacher autonomy and growth. See my blog posting about Vail, AZ and their move away from textbooks at: http://johnfaig.blogspot.com
Jennifer Leighton June 26, 2009 at 07:35pm
that is a good point zoe. we actually have a lap top program in maine, here's my thought what would happen if the kindle was misused? in maine we students have actually lost laptops for misuse. what will happen if the student actually loses a kindle that is there text book?
Rosalyn Williams June 24, 2009 at 02:28pm
I think the shift toward technology is imminent. Although perhaps not in the coming 5 years, eventually the classroom will be dominated by computers. With the rise of the extremely cheap netbook, a lot of text books can cost as much or even more than a computer. This Kindle may not be the terminator of the text book, but one is certainly in the near future.
Betty Miller June 24, 2009 at 08:31pm
I think textbooks will be obsolete about the time they are printed. There is no way to keep up with technology. The only real problem that I personally have is that staring at a computer screen all day can be a bit much for one's posture and eyesight. I find that books are much easier to take for long periods at a time. That's just me.
John Faig June 24, 2009 at 10:17pm
Betty,

I agree that looking at a computer screen is somewhat limiting. It is too small and is not like a desk where papers can be piled. Just because the content is digitized, does not me you have to view it on screen. You could print it out as necessary. Keep in mind that digital allows users to modify it. This means that other teachers could lend a hand with your curriculum. In addition, how about a curriculum that students help develop for other students.

JDF
Annie Condron June 26, 2009 at 05:14pm
Just read that there's a cheaper version of the kindle in the pipeline... the change may be coming sooner than ya think
http://www.eschoolnews.com/news/top-news/index.cfm?i=59397

My TeachHUB.com

Become a FREE TeachHUB.com
Member

 

  • Members-only discounts
  • Free (& super fun!) quarterly gifts
  • Free weekly e-newsletter
  • Share photos, lessons & stories
  • Free stuff, contests and deals!

 

sign up for free
member login

TeachHUB Contests

Enter to win $100 donation to an extra-curricular program at your school.

Get details!

 

Spa Giveaway

TeachHUB Spa Giveaway

Enter daily to increase your chances of winning $100 in spa certificates!

Enter Spa Giveaway!

 

Advertisement

Teacher Blogs on TeachHUB

 

Classroom Tales

From the Bronx

Phil Tabernacle

 

 

Science Under

the Microscope

Paul Cancellieri

 

The Chalk

Talks

Jennifer Scoggin

 

 

Ed Tech

Made Easy

Cheryl Oakes

 

 

TeachHUB Blog

TeachHUB Team